All products featured on No Kill Mag are independently selected by our editors. However, when you buy something through our retail links, we may earn an affiliate commission.
Looking for a cute pair of shoes that you can dress up for a night out or dress down for a casual day trip? Look no further than a pair of Mary Janes! Mary Janes are a timeless classic shoe that look similar to a ballet flat. They were popularized by the famous comic strip Buster Brown in the 1950s after appearing on a character of the same name.
Mary Janes have recently returned to the spotlight thanks to the rise of coquette/ballerina style, along with bows, pearls, and lace. Plenty of Mary Jane options exist, but many are produced by fast-fashion brands and made from wasteful materials such as polyurethane.
Below we’ve compiled a list of 5 pairs of Mary Janes from No-Kill approved brands that are ethically made, super stylish, and keep sustainability in mind!
Vivaia Square-Toe Mary Janes
This square-toe Mary Jane from Vivaia is a great option, with the knit upper made from plastic bottles and the insole made of Natural Artemisia Argyi. The added heel padding protects against stubborn blisters and make them easy to break in, while the anti-slip sole allows for you to keep you feet on the ground! This pair comes in many colors and patterns, making them perfect for everyday use or a formal dinner!
Cayumas Boheme Rosa Bordeaux Mary Jane
Made in artisan workshops in Northern Italy, this pair of Mary Janes is hand sewn with organic velvet and English Liberty fabrics and recycled rubber from bicycle wheels on the sole! The classic rounded toe, nickel-free buckle, and adjustable strap make this stylish pair is sure to impress.
Rothy’s The Mary Jane Heels
This heeled variation of a Mary Jane is perfect for those looking for a bit of extra height! This 2’ heeled version features their innovative IN LOVE INSOLE™ COMFORT, allowing for cushion-like support for your feet. This premium knit spun from plastic bottles includes a slim cross strap with buckle detail, and is available in many colors from black, to wine red, to ballerina!
Reformation Melissa Mary Jane Flats
This pick from Reformation offers a more classic, ballerina-like take of Mary Jane Flats, complete with a square toe, flat heel, and cross trap with buckle detail. They come in a fun leopard print made of crepe fabric if you want to add a pop of a pattern, but are also available in suede, nappa, or leather.
Suzanna Rae High Closed Mary Janes
This pick is a nod to a more classic style of Mary Janes from Suzanna Rae. This pair, made in Italy, features a high-closed style with a gold buckle, a square toe, Italian leather soles, and a 3” block heel—perfect for wearing to work or to a nice dinner!
